Posts Tagged ‘ classical liberal ’

‘New York’ Magazine Critique of Libertarianism Has Positive Unintended Consequences

January 11, 2011
By
‘New York’ Magazine Critique of Libertarianism Has Positive Unintended Consequences

A recent New York magazine article has raised a bit of a ruckus on the right. In his long article on libertarianism, Christopher Beam appears both fascinated and puzzled by the odd phenomenon under his microscope. Anyone at all familiar with libertarianism will recognize that his characterization of the movement and the philosophy behind it is something of a caricature, but there is a serious critique to be found in his article. That critique is seriously wrong, as it happens, and understanding just where Beam goes wrong could go a long way toward helping libertarians, conservatives, classical liberals, and others on the right better understand the foundations of our thought and the opportunities for a mass movement it may afford. Too often we tend to argue as vigorously over our differences with one another as we do with those whose big-government policies are the real adversary. What we share, however, is the foundation for a truly American mass political movement. Beam, for his part, understands that the movement has developed a strong following among more than just fringe types in recent months: There’s never been a better time to be a libertarian than now. The right is still railing against

Read more »

William F. Buckley and the Modern American Right

February 27, 2008
By
William F. Buckley and the Modern American Right

William F. Buckley, author, columnist, TV talk show host, and founding editor of National Review magazine, died today at age 82. Buckley was one of the people most responsible for making the conservative movement a powerful force in the United States during the past six decades. Especially through his influential magazine, Buckley set the agenda for the American right and made it appealing to a mass audience. His editorial approach and political philosophy combined to create an ecumenism on the right that allowed the various factions to work together, although the relationships have always been strained to some degree. However, his stolid opposition to statism in all of its forms provided a rallying cry for the American right and continues to do so.

Read more »

On the Ground in Iraq – The Logical Limits of Sympathy

February 12, 2008
By

As regular readers of this site and my other writings know, I believe that the U.S. presence in Iraq served its purpose—the removal of the presumed threat to American lives within our borders (however plausible that threat may have been)—some time ago, with the removal of Saddam Hussein from power. Given that all individuals and all peoples have the right of self-defense, anything that happened thereafter, according to classical liberal principles, was neither our responsibility nor any business of ours, unless it should come to pose a plausible threat to American citizens within our borders once again. As I have argued in the past, I am hopeful that the U.S. military surge in Iraq will put an end to our involvement there, and soon. Nonetheless, I sympathize with the plight of the Iraqi population under attack by brutally violent Muslim fanatics under the aegis of al Qaeda. Thus I agree fully with Rich Lowry, a strong supporter of the Iraq War, in his assessment of the situation facing the Iraqi people, in today’s National Review Online:

Read more »

The Simpsons Movie

July 27, 2007
By
The Simpsons Movie

If you ever liked the Simpsons TV series, you’ll enjoy The Simspsons Movie. It’s basically a long episode of the series, but the film never becomes boring. The animation looks fine, the characters are as we always knew and enjoyed them, and the humorous dialogue lines are as funny as ever. There’s rather too much Lisa for my taste—Lisa represents the cause-y and sentimental sides of the program, which are the aspects I enjoy the least. Similarly, Bart is given an emotional crisis that takes away from his usual humorous role as a force of nature. He’s nowhere near as funny here as he was during the show’s early years, but Homer replaced Bart as the center of the program a decade and a half ago, so we probably should be used to it by now. But alas, anyway.

Read more »

Was Mill a Classical Liberal?

May 30, 2007
By
Was Mill a Classical Liberal?

Short answer: Not always and in every way. The question arose when my Tech Central Station article outlining a classical liberal view of the Iraq War brought criticism from my friends at the American Spectator, on the AmSpec Blog:

Read more »

Does Classical Liberalism Work in Foreign Affairs?

May 29, 2007
By

A commenter suggests that classical liberal principles are an impractical guide to international issues. Susan Behrend writes, You are forgetting one thing – leaving a chaotic Afghanistan to the Taliban led directly to the 9/11 attacks. When the Soviets left, the world community just left the Afghans to sort it all out. They didn’t do a very good job of it. . . . We can’t leave Iraq to descend into becoming a failed state, unable to prevent al-Qaeda from establishing training camps. It is too easy for them to acquire weapons and transport them to our shores. THe problem with the pure ideology of classical liberalism is that its very purity makes it impractical in the real world. . . . What you say may be consistent with Locke et al, but it may not be consistent with keeping this country safe from harm

Read more »

A Classical Liberal View of the Proposed Iraq “Surge”

May 2, 2007
By

Having gone on record as arguing that the classical liberal position suggests that it is high time that the United States extricate its military troops from Iraq (here and here), the question then beomes, How? One way could be the troop surge that President Bush proposes.

Read more »

A Classical Liberal View of the Iraq War

April 30, 2007
By
A Classical Liberal View of the Iraq War

Citing public opinion polls and Congress’s vote to require a timetable for the United States to leave Iraq, conservative stalwart commentator William F. Buckley suggests that the very existence of the Republican Party is at state. This seems a real stretch, given that the Democratic Party not only survived Vietnam but in fact routed the Republicans just one presidency later. But the situation for the Republicans is indeed dire, as Buckley argues in referring to the chances of a positive outcome for the United States in Iraq:

Read more »

More on Classical Liberalism

November 14, 2006
By

In my article yesterday in National Review Online, and in subsequent discussions here, I have suggested a return to the philosophy of classical liberalism as an antidote to both big-government conservatism (the current-day Republicans) and what I call New Age conservatism (the current-day Democrats). As I pointed out six months ago on Tech Central Station, big-government conservatism is a mess both politically and as policy . And the Democrats’ success in the recent elections suggests that they will stick with their New Age conservatism for the near future. Conservatism, then, is a position for Democrats for the near future. And in my view, they can have it. This nation does not need conservatism; it needs reform. Badly. Hence, the Republicans really should look to liberalism as their way out of the woods. Fortunately, classical liberalism is a philosophy that is both easy to understand and easy to like. Here is how I outlined it in my Tech Central Station article on "The Crash of Big-Government Conservatism": The solution for the Republicans, then, must be philosophical at heart, and that philosophy must drive the party’s policy prescriptions. Their only real answer is to embrace classical liberalism. This includes in particular embracing

Read more »


"Culture is the expression of the guiding philosophy of the day."—Murray Rothbard

Subscribe to The American Culture.

 

February 2012
S M T W T F S
« Jan    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829  

Archive

Twitter Feed!

Follow the American Culture and S. T. Karnick on Twitter! Send message "follow stkarnick1" to 40404 on your cell phone or go to twitter.com.

Packages Seo